The long-standing rivalry between Ford and Chevrolet has officially entered the EV era, and Ford just scored a decisive win. In a recent head-to-head comparison hosted by AutoGuide.com, the Ford F-150 Lightning emerged as the superior all-electric pickup, besting the Chevy Silverado EV in multiple categories, including functionality, ride comfort, and overall truck-like authenticity.

AutoGuide’s test put the two electric pickups through real-world evaluations. The Silverado EV was praised for its agility, thanks to four-wheel steering that made tight maneuvers easier. However, it struggled in terms of design and utility. The truck’s styling was likened more to the discontinued Chevy Avalanche than the traditional Silverado, and its tailgate—while clever—lacks the remote-open function that the F-150 Lightning offers as standard. In contrast, reviewers noted that the Lightning stays true to its F-Series roots, simply “a regular F-150 that happens to be electric.”

Comfort and ride quality also tipped the scale in Ford’s favor. While both trucks are impressive, reviewers described the F-150 Lightning as offering a smoother, more refined ride. Editor Kyle Patrick highlighted how the Lightning feels like a natural extension of the best-selling F-150 lineup: familiar, rugged, and versatile, with the added benefits of electric power.

Ultimately, the Ford F-150 Lightning was named the winner of this comparison, not just for being a capable EV, but for being a great truck first and foremost. It continues to outperform major competitors, including the Rivian R1T and Tesla Cybertruck. For anyone seeking a true truck experience in an electric package, the F-150 Lightning proves that Ford’s leadership in the pickup segment is far from over.